DISQUS

DISQUS Hello! Major League Soccer Talk is using DISQUS, a powerful comment system, to manage its comments. Learn more.

Community Page

Major League Soccer Talk

MLS News & Analysis
Jump to original thread »
Author

European Football vs American Soccer

Started by The Gaffer · 7 months ago

My colleague at the Champions Soccer Radio Network, Daniel Feuerstein has a very interesting take on what now seems like an age old question: Has Soccer arrived?  Much along the same lines as my column over the weekend about how MLS Cup garnered about one fourth of the total v ... Continue reading »

4 comments

  • undrafted

    7 months ago

    "I’ve seen a dip in quality in the league"

    debatable, the depth in the 90s was horrible and very few expensive imports were brought in around the time of contraction in 2002. I think expansion to 14 has caused some regression since the 10 team league of 2004 but it's a tough call. Guys like Burciaga, Nick Garcia, and Jim Curtin have seen MLS progress beyond their talent. Midfielders (but for DM's) have generally regressed in quailty the last 5 years. The strikers are a better at the top end but overall about the same. The GK's were building up a strong pool until the recent mass exodus (Pickens, Perkins, Guzan). I tend to measure quality of play by the weakest links on the field and those are generally better now than those from 1996-2002.

    "and fewer and fewer good young American players being developed in MLS."

    I can't imagine this is true. Please provide some examples (in some sort of quantifiable list).
    reply
  • Cavan

    7 months ago

    It's not. Adu, Altidore, Bradley, Rogers, Gaven, Bornstein, Klesjian, Boswell, King, Stammler, Franklin, Ashe, Parkhurst, and so on.

    There hasn't been a drop. Some games have been tighter because the tactics have gotten more sophisticated. Recently, Comcast SportsNet had all the DC United MLS Cup games on back to back. It was striking how much more time players had to make decisions with the ball back in the early games vs. the 2004 game. Considering that, the team shapes are far simpler in the 2004 game than what we saw this year between the Crew and Red Bulls.
    reply
  • Cavan

    7 months ago

    He does make a fair point about the TV ratings. They're clearly not where we want them to be.
    reply
  • Jonathan

    7 months ago

    I posted this on Kartik's other blog:

    I'm a naturalized American who likes football. I support the USMNT even as it got humiliated in the Copa. One thing I won't do is be a fan of the domestic league. I will spend my time as I see fit when watching football. IT is my free time afterall.
    reply

Add New Comment

Returning? Login